Mythic+ conduct signals
Know the group before the key starts.
One bad review isn't a signal. One failed run isn't a signal. One guild's grudge isn't a signal. PugProof only surfaces conduct that's repeated, independent, and corroborated — never skill, never public comments, never a blacklist.
Reading the signal
Six plain-language states. No raw scores.
The addon and site only ever show an aggregate state — never a toxic score, raw averages, or rater names.
- Great teammateFrequently marked as a great teammate.
- Mostly positiveMostly positive verified group history.
- No data yetNot enough verified group history yet.
- Mixed feedbackMixed verified group feedback.
- Recent cautionMultiple independent recent conduct cautions.
- Severe cautionRepeated independent conduct cautions over recent group history.
Hall of fame
This season's standout teammates.
Players most often marked as great teammates across independent verified runs. Positive recognition only — there is no public worst list, by design.
- FrostlureArea 52★ Great teammate
31 positive ratings · 22 verified runs
- ThornwildStormrage★ Great teammate
27 positive ratings · 19 verified runs
- LightwardenIllidan★ Great teammate
24 positive ratings · 18 verified runs
- MistveilProudmoore★ Great teammate
22 positive ratings · 16 verified runs
- StormhowlSargeras★ Great teammate
19 positive ratings · 15 verified runs
- DuskbladeTichondrius★ Great teammate
18 positive ratings · 14 verified runs
A public caution needs at least 3 independent incident clusters, from 3 distinct raters, across 2+ different days, within 90 days. Four players from one wipe count as one cluster — not four reports.
Typed notes are visible to moderators only. They're scanned for slurs, threats, and personal info, and are never exported to the addon or attached to a public signal.
Signals fade with time — roughly a 90-day half-life — so a rough patch doesn't define someone forever. Appeals exist before any public caution is shown.
Boundaries
What PugProof is not.
The design says no to the things that turn reputation tools into harassment tools.
- A skill, DPS, or parse ranking
- A blacklist or wall of shame
- A public comment board
- An auto-decline group filter
- A "most toxic players" list
- A way to see who rated you
How the data moves
Local capture, server-side weighting, cacheable lookup.
Evidence is gathered on your machine and moved by a companion app — the way Wowhead and TSM do it — so gameplay stays smooth and the public signal is just a snapshot.
- Addon records local group rosters and post-run ratings on your machine
- Companion app uploads validated batches to the API
- Server separates private notes from public, weighted signals
- Worker clusters incidents and exports a cacheable snapshot